73 Arkell Street: Real Value in Westdale Without the Usual Spin

There is a lot of noise in real estate right now.

Every listing is “rare.” Every kitchen is “chef-inspired.” Every backyard is an “oasis.” It gets old fast.

So let’s talk about 73 Arkell Street the normal way.

This is a 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom detached home in Westdale with 1,285 square feet above grade, an 811 square foot unfinished basement, parking for 5, and a detached garage. It sits on a 30 x 100 foot lot in one of Hamilton’s most established, walkable, and consistently desirable neighbourhoods.

And more importantly, the expensive stuff has been done.

Westdale Is Still One of Hamilton’s Best Pockets

Westdale works because it gives people options.

You have character homes, mature trees, walkable streets, parks, schools, coffee shops, restaurants, trails, transit, highway access, and McMaster University all close by. That is a pretty strong mix.

For families, the school access is a major part of the story. The listing notes Westdale, St. Mary, Cathedral, Cootes, Dalewood, St. Joe, and Canadian Martyrs as nearby schools.

For McMaster staff, doctors, residents, researchers, professors, or anyone tied to the university or hospital network, the location is obvious. You are close enough to the action without feeling like you bought a student rental with a front door hanging on for dear life.

Westdale has plenty of homes that have been beaten up, chopped up, rented hard, patched together, and sent back to market with a coat of paint and crossed fingers.

This is not that.

The Main Floor Is the Money

The main floor is where this house really separates itself.

In 2018, the main floor was taken back and rebuilt with new drywall, plumbing, electrical, a full kitchen renovation, updated bathrooms, restored original flooring, replaced windows in key areas, and a much more usable layout.

The kitchen is the centre of the house, and it actually feels like a place people will use every day. You have Hallmark cabinetry, Calacatta-style quartz counters with integrated backsplash, Frigidaire Professional Series appliances, a second island sink, carbon water filtration, and enough room for proper cooking, eating, and hanging out without everyone standing in one awkward corner pretending they are not in the way.

It is bright, open, clean, and still has warmth.

That is the part a lot of renovations miss. They make everything new, but the house loses its soul. This one kept the original floors and character where it made sense, then added the updates where they actually matter.

Three Bedrooms, With Some Real Flexibility

The home has one bedroom on the main floor and two bedrooms upstairs.

The main floor bedroom is interesting because it gives the house flexibility. It can be used as a bedroom, office, family room extension, guest space, or potentially part of a future main floor laundry plan.

Right now, laundry is in the basement. That is not unusual for a home of this age, but it is also not everyone’s favourite setup. The good news is that the main floor bedroom gives you options. For someone who wants easier day-to-day living, moving laundry to the main level could make a lot of sense.

Upstairs, the two bedrooms work well as traditional bedrooms, but there is also a better-than-average lifestyle play here. The second upstairs bedroom could be converted into a walk-in closet or dressing room connected to the primary bedroom.

Is that for everyone? No.

But for a couple, single professional, McMaster-connected buyer, or someone who wants a boutique hotel feel at home, it could be fantastic. Also, it’s worked very well for a young family for well over a decade.

The Basement Is Not Being Oversold

Let’s be honest about the basement.

It is unfinished. It has low points. It is an older Hamilton basement.

That means this is not the house where I would pretend you are getting some massive finished rec room, gym, theatre, golf simulator, wine cave, hockey shrine, and underground nightclub.

You are not.

What you are getting is useful unfinished space with storage, laundry, upgraded mechanicals, and potential depending on what a buyer needs. The floor plan shows the basement at 811 square feet of unfinished space.

Could someone improve it? Probably.

Should anyone pretend it is the main event? No.

The value here is in the main and second floor living space, the location, the updates, the exterior work, the garage, and the long-term flexibility.

The Exterior Has Had Serious Work Too

This is where the value gets pretty hard to ignore.

In 2018, the exterior saw a long list of upgrades: rebuilt front porch with tongue-and-groove pine ceiling and pot lights, panelled front door with keyless entry, Ipe deck, exterior repainting, fascia, soffits, eaves, shingles, artificial turf landscaping, pergola with electrical, new side door, aluminum flashing on basement windows, and low-maintenance perennial gardens.

That is not fluff. That is real money.

The garage was also lifted and rebuilt with a new concrete pad, new framing, spray foam insulation, new shingles, soffits, fascia, eaves, electrical, exhaust ventilation, and an additional shed at the rear.

Again, real money.

There was also prior exterior work in 2015, including waterproofing on the driveway side and rear of the house with new weeping tile, plus exposed aggregate driveway, patios, and walkways.

This is the kind of work buyers should care about.

Paint colours are easy. Throw pillows are easy. A bathroom mirror from Wayfair is easy.

Waterproofing, roofing, exterior work, porches, decks, garage rebuilds, electrical, plumbing, and mechanicals are where the money disappears.

Here, a lot of that work has already been handled.

McMaster Proximity Adds Real Opportunity

Being this close to McMaster is a big deal.

That does not mean this has to become a student rental. In fact, I would argue this house is too good to be treated like one. Many of the neighbouring homes are young families. This area is a blend of each.

But the location gives the property extra layers of value.

You have potential demand from visiting professors, medical residents, researchers, families visiting students, academic professionals, hospital-connected buyers, and people who want short-term furnished accommodation near the university.

The home has already doubled as a successful Airbnb, which adds another angle for the right buyer.

Close to McMaster. Close to amenities. In a neighbourhood people actually want to stay in. That is a strong setup.

What’s It Worth?

This may not be the perfect house for everyone. If you’re looking for a 4-bedroom home with ensuite bathrooms, 60×120 lot, 7’ ceilings in the basement, that hasn’t been rundown by students, I can show you that in Westdale, but expect to spend $1,500,000 or more.

73 Arkell is offering tremendous value. Similar homes have recently sold for $100/sqft or more and average and median prices are higher too. The Municipal Property Assessment Corporation (MPAC) has an Average Market Value (AVM) report based on 16 sales in the area. This report values this home at $803,000, stay with me… that is in 2016 and described as fair/poor condition. Add on $100,000-$120,000 in upgrades and updates and this is an absolute bargain at $813,000.

MORE INFO HERE:

Thank you for reading and let me know when you’re ready to see this beauty in person!

Andrew